On this page
- Most Websites an AI Answer Cites Are Not on Google's First Page
- Google AI Mode's Sources Sit on Page One Twice as Often as ChatGPT's
- A Fifth of Google's First Page Is Forums and Social Sites ChatGPT Skips
- What ChatGPT Cites Instead Is the Companies It Names
- Many Buyer Questions Share Nothing With Page One
- A Top Google Position Helps Most in Google AI Mode
- Your Search Reports Cannot See Which Sources an Answer Cites
- Frequently asked questions
If your company pays someone to look after search, a report lands every month with your Google positions for the questions buyers type. Page one reads as good news, and for years it was a fair stand-in for being found.
Buyers now ask an assistant along the way: in Forrester's 2025 survey of business buyers, 94% used AI somewhere in their buying process, and twice as many named generative AI or conversational search as a more meaningful source than any other, ahead of vendor websites, product experts and sales1.
Which raises a fair question about the rank report: if Google puts us on page one, are ChatGPT and Google AI Mode, Google's chat-style search answers, citing us too?
We took buyer questions of the kind Qvery's GEO Agent asks every day and put each one to Google Search, ChatGPT and Google AI Mode on the same day, then compared the websites each one pointed to.
89.6% of the websites ChatGPT cited were not on Google's first page for the same question, and 76.8% of the websites Google AI Mode cited were not there either.
Forums and social sites fill a fifth of Google's first page and almost none of ChatGPT's citations; what ChatGPT cites instead is mostly the websites of the companies its answer names.
So a page-one position says little about whether the answers cite you, and none of the reports a company already gets shows which websites the answers do cite.
One caveat before the numbers: this is one day of answers in the US, compared by website, and a citation is a source link, not a lead.
Most Websites an AI Answer Cites Are Not on Google's First Page
Our research used a sample of the US buyer questions the GEO Agent tracks, from three-word searches to paragraph-long requests about software, services, insurance and travel, each put to ChatGPT with web search on and to Google AI Mode, and searched on Google US, all on 15 October 2026.
Matched by website, 10.4% of the websites ChatGPT cited were on Google's first page for the same question. For Google AI Mode it was 23.2%.
Matched by exact page, the figures fall to 1.9% and 7.6%. When an answer and Google agree on a website, they usually point at different pages of it.
Few Cited Websites, and Fewer Pages, Sit on Google's First Page
% of cited websites or pages
View the data
| Label | Same exact page | Same website | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 1.9% | 10.4% | 98.1% of the pages ChatGPT cited were not on Google's first page. |
| Google AI Mode | 7.6% | 23.2% | 92.4% of the pages Google AI Mode cited were not on Google's first page. |
Researchers at Ruhr University Bochum and the Max Planck Institute for Software Systems saw the same gap on 4,706 general queries in September 2025. Fewer than half of the links in Google's AI Overviews, the AI summary above the results, were in Google's top 10 for the same query, and OpenAI's GPT-4o search model overlapped substantially less2.
Google AI Mode's Sources Sit on Page One Twice as Often as ChatGPT's
Google AI Mode's citations sat on Google's first page more than twice as often as ChatGPT's, 23.2% against 10.4%.
Google says a page must be indexed and eligible to show in Search with a snippet to appear as a supporting link in AI Mode, with no additional technical requirements3. That makes Google's index the pool AI Mode draws from.
It also says AI Mode may use a query fan-out, one question turned into multiple related searches across subtopics and data sources, and shows a wider and more diverse set of links than a classic web search3. That is one documented route by which a page outside the top ten becomes a source.
OpenAI describes the same move from its side: when ChatGPT search works with outside search providers, it typically rewrites your question into one or more targeted queries and sends those4. Either way, one buyer question can become several searches that no rank report tracks.

The two engines also disagree with each other. Of the websites ChatGPT cited, only 9.8% were cited by Google AI Mode for the same question. A company can be in one engine's answer and missing from the other's, on the same day.
Piotr BabelPartner @ QveryOnly 9.8% of the websites ChatGPT cited were also cited by Google AI Mode for the same question, so one visibility score blended across both engines hides the engine you are missing from. To see it on your own brand, the GEO Agent runs your buyers' questions on both engines every day and records every citation. Read the two side by side, and judge a gap over several weeks of answers.
A Fifth of Google's First Page Is Forums and Social Sites ChatGPT Skips
Reddit was on page one for 59.8% of these buyer questions. ChatGPT cited Reddit in 0.4% of its answers. Google AI Mode cited it in 14.8%.
Forums Fill Google's First Page and Barely Reach ChatGPT
% of questions or answers
View the data
| Label | Cited by ChatGPT | On Google's first page | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.4% | 59.8% | Google AI Mode cited Reddit in 14.8% of its answers. | |
| 0.0% | 39.5% | Google AI Mode cited Facebook in 3.1% of its answers. | |
| YouTube | 0.0% | 30.9% | Google AI Mode cited YouTube in 12.9% of its answers. |
| Quora | 0.0% | 21.5% | Google AI Mode did not cite Quora in any answer either. |
| 1.2% | 10.5% | Google AI Mode cited LinkedIn in 3.9% of its answers. |
Across community and social sites (Reddit, Quora, Facebook, YouTube, LinkedIn, Medium and the like), the split holds. They are 20.9% of the websites on Google's first page and 0.3% of the websites ChatGPT cited, with Google AI Mode between them at 12.5%. Quora is the extreme case: on page one for 21.5% of the questions, and cited by neither engine in a single answer.
The academic study saw the same thing on its own queries: Google's organic results included up to 35% social media and user forums, and few such domains turned up among the GPT models' sources2.
Reddit, Tripadvisor and YouTube were the three sites most often found in an answer and on page one for the same question, 17.8% of all matches, and 81.4% of those matches came through Google AI Mode.
For a company, that sorts the forum work by engine. A thread that ranks for your buyer's question is a Google result and sometimes a Google AI Mode source. In ChatGPT's answers, it almost never appears.
What ChatGPT Cites Instead Is the Companies It Names
If ChatGPT is not citing the forums, it is citing the companies it puts in front of the buyer. 64.7% of the websites ChatGPT cited belonged to a company or organization its answer named. For Google AI Mode the figure was 35.8%.
Run the same test on Google's first page: only 5.6% of the websites on page one were named in ChatGPT's answer to the same question, and 6.7% in Google AI Mode's.
ChatGPT Mostly Cites the Companies It Names
% of websites
View the data
| Label | Google's first-page websites | Websites the answer cited | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 5.6% | 64.7% | Of the websites on Google's first page, 5.6% were named in ChatGPT's answer to the same question. |
| Google AI Mode | 6.7% | 35.8% | Of the websites on Google's first page, 6.7% were named in Google AI Mode's answer. |
The test misses companies whose name differs from their domain, so 64.7% is a floor.
Vlad ShvetsPartner @ QveryMost of the websites ChatGPT cited were the sites of companies its answer named. Those sites are what its shortlists rest on, so the plain facts on yours, what you do, for whom, where and on what terms, are part of how you get sold now, and keeping them right is a separate job from ranking the page.
Many Buyer Questions Share Nothing With Page One
The averages hide how often the two lists have nothing in common. Of the answers that cited anything, 61.3% of ChatGPT's shared no website with Google's top 10, and 49.4% of Google AI Mode's did the same.
The median ChatGPT answer overlapped by 0.0%; the median AI Mode answer, by 14.3%.
Most ChatGPT Answers Share No Website With Page One
% of answers
View the data
| Label | ChatGPT | Google AI Mode |
|---|---|---|
| None on page one | 61.3% | 49.4% |
| Some, under a quarter | 16.0% | 4.6% |
| A quarter to a half | 15.6% | 22.0% |
| Half or more | 7.0% | 24.1% |
Long questions leave more answers with nothing in common. Google says the average AI Mode search in the US is triple the length of a traditional Search query5.
In our set, 66.7% of ChatGPT's answers to questions of twelve words or more shared no website with page one, against 52.2% for questions of six words or fewer. For Google AI Mode it was 52.2% against 48.5%.
A rank report built on short phrases measures the kind of question least like the ones buyers now type into an assistant.
A Top Google Position Helps Most in Google AI Mode
Of the websites on Google's first page for these questions, ChatGPT cited 6.9% and Google AI Mode 8.0%. 87.3% were cited by neither.
Position matters more in Google AI Mode. The site in first position was cited by AI Mode 18.4% of the time; by position ten, 2.3%. ChatGPT's line is flatter and noisier: 10.9% at the top, 3.4% at the bottom, and between 4.2% and 9.1% in the positions between.
Higher Positions Are Cited More, Mostly by Google AI Mode
% of websites at that position
View the data
| Label | ChatGPT | Google AI Mode |
|---|---|---|
| #1 | 10.9% | 18.4% |
| #2 | 6.9% | 11.8% |
| #3 | 6.9% | 10.8% |
| #4 | 9.1% | 6.0% |
| #5 | 7.7% | 9.0% |
| #6 | 5.0% | 4.6% |
| #7 | 4.2% | 3.8% |
| #8 | 6.2% | 5.3% |
| #9 | 7.1% | 4.7% |
| #10 | 3.4% | 2.3% |
Google's own guidance points the same way: specific optimization isn't required for AI Mode, and existing SEO fundamentals continue to be worthwhile3.
So the ranking work keeps its value, though the link between position and citation is an association, not a cause we can show. It cannot be read as an AI report: even the site in first position was cited by either engine for only 23.8% of these questions.
Your Search Reports Cannot See Which Sources an Answer Cites
The reports a company already gets were built for ten blue links.
| Report | What it shows | What it cannot show |
|---|---|---|
| Rank report | Your Google position for each tracked question | Whether an AI answer names you, or which sites it cites |
| Search Console's generative AI report | Impressions in AI Overviews and AI Mode, by page, country, date and device6 | Which question surfaced you, the other sites cited, anything about ChatGPT |
| Web analytics | The visits that arrive through a click, from any engine | The answers read without one |
Analytics is the weakest of the three, because few people who see an AI summary click anything. In Pew Research Center's browsing data, Google users who saw one clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits, against 15% when none appeared, and a link inside the summary in 1%7.
An answer is built and read before anyone clicks, so the only way to see it is to ask the buyer's question and keep the answer.
Answers also move between asks: the academic study found that generative search outputs vary across time and between runs of the same query2. Read any single check, ours included, as one day, and judge a change over several weeks.
Seeing which sources the answers cite for your own questions takes the same questions, asked again on a schedule, with every answer kept.
For ChatGPT, where the answers neither cite nor name you, the fix starts on your own site.
Our team reads the daily answers with you, and your pipeline owner approves what goes out.
If the answers to the questions that matter already cite and name you, your rank report is enough for now. If they don't, and the report still says page one, you have found the part of your distribution nobody looks after yet.
Frequently asked questions
If we rank on Google's first page, will AI answers cite us?
Not reliably. In our same-day comparison of buyer questions, ChatGPT cited 6.9% and Google AI Mode 8.0% of the websites on Google's first page, and even the site in first position was cited by either engine for only 23.8% of the questions. Higher positions go with more citations in Google AI Mode than in ChatGPT, as an association, not a proven effect.
Should we cut our SEO budget because of this?
No. Google says existing SEO fundamentals continue to be worthwhile for its AI features3, and in our data a higher position went with more Google AI Mode citations. The finding is narrower: rank tracking stays useful for Google, and AI answers need a check of their own.
Why do studies of AI citations and Google rankings report such different overlap figures?
They match differently and compare against different lists. Matching the exact page gives a far lower figure than matching the website: 1.9% against 10.4% for ChatGPT in our data. Comparing against more of Google's results raises it: in the Bochum and Max Planck study, Google's AI Overviews overlapped with the top 10 by under half and with the top 100 by under 60%2. The kind of question moves it too.
Does Google Search Console show AI citations?
Partly. Its generative AI report shows impressions of your pages in AI Overviews and AI Mode, by page, country, date and device6. It does not show which questions triggered them, which other sites the answer cited, or anything about ChatGPT.
Why does ChatGPT almost never cite Reddit when Google ranks it so often?
Our data shows the gap, not its cause. Reddit was on Google's first page for 59.8% of these buyer questions and in 0.4% of ChatGPT's answers, while Google AI Mode cited it in 14.8%. The academic study found the same pattern: up to 35% social media and forums in Google's results, few such sites among the GPT models' sources2.
Is being cited the same as being recommended?
No. A citation is a source link, a mention is a named company, and a recommendation is one the buyer is told to consider. 64.7% of ChatGPT's cited websites belonged to named companies, yet a cited review page can name your competitor.
How often should we check which sources AI answers cite for us?
Often enough to see change, because answers vary between runs of the same question2. A monthly check by hand on a short list is a reasonable start; once the list runs past what one person can ask and record in an afternoon, or covers several markets, a weekly run suits an agent.
Who should own this in a company our size?
Whoever owns the pipeline. The agency or freelancer who sends the rank report can collect the answers, but the person who decides where marketing effort goes should read them, because the gap they show sits between that report and what buyers read.
Do ChatGPT and Google AI Mode cite the same websites?
Rarely, in our comparison. Only 9.8% of the websites ChatGPT cited were also cited by Google AI Mode for the same question, so a company can be in one engine's answer and missing from the other's on the same day.
Why does Google AI Mode cite page-one websites more often than ChatGPT?
In our data, 23.2% of the websites Google AI Mode cited were on Google's first page, against 10.4% for ChatGPT. Google says a page must be indexed and eligible to show in Search with a snippet to appear as a supporting link in AI Mode3, so Google's index is its pool.
Do longer buyer questions change how AI answers line up with Google?
Mostly for ChatGPT. 66.7% of its answers to questions of twelve words or more shared no website with page one, against 52.2% for six words or fewer; Google AI Mode's split was 52.2% against 48.5%. Google says the average AI Mode search in the US is triple the length of a traditional one5.
Can our web analytics show what AI answers do for us?
Only the visits that arrive through a click. In Pew Research Center's browsing data, Google users who saw an AI summary clicked a link inside it in 1% of visits7. An answer read without a click never reaches your analytics.
How far can we trust a one-day comparison like this one?
As a snapshot, not a census. It is one day of answers in the US, in English, compared by website, and the questions lean toward software and services buyers, with travel, insurance and local services among them. It shows which websites appeared together, not why an engine chose them.
Sources
- Forrester: B2B Buyers Make Zero-Click Number One (2026)
- arXiv (Ruhr University Bochum; Max Planck Institute for Software Systems): Characterizing Web Search in The Age of Generative AI (2025)
- Google Search Central: AI features and your website (2026)
- OpenAI Help Center: Searching the web with ChatGPT (2026)
- Google: How AI Mode is changing the way people search in the U.S. (2026)
- Google Search Console Help: Generative AI performance report (Search) (2026)
- Pew Research Center: Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears in the results (2025)