# 73 Outsourcing Contract and Dispute Statistics

> Contracts lose 8.6% of their value on average to how they are formed and managed, while an ICC arbitration that reached a final award in 2025 took 27 months on average.

By Piotr Babel, Partner @ Qvery · Published 2026-11-15 · 13 min read
Canonical: https://qvery.ai/blog/outsourcing-contract-dispute-statistics/

At a business process outsourcing (BPO) firm that runs contact centers or service desks for clients, each client contract sets its own service levels: which calls or tickets count, how response time is measured, which hours are excluded, and what credit the client gets when a target is missed.

Every month someone on your team works those out from the phone and ticket exports, client by client.

When a credit is read the client's way, the difference is part of one month's fee, which can look too small to argue over.

Across contracts of every kind, World Commerce & Contracting (WorldCC), the association for contract and commercial management, estimates with Deloitte that companies lose **8.6%** of contract value on average to the way their contracts are formed and managed.[^1]

Each figure on this page names who measured it and on whom, because most come from surveys of the companies that buy services and from contracts of every kind, not from outsourcing providers alone.

> 💡 **Highlights** 
> - Contracts lose **8.6%** of their value on average, a little over **3%** at the best performers and more than **20%** at the worst.[^1]
> - **48%** of respondents to WorldCC's 2025 benchmark say nobody clearly owns the quality of their contracting.[^2]
> - **55%** of the outsourcing buyers Deloitte surveyed name tracking and reporting the benefit as a challenge, the one named most.[^3]
> - **70%** of them have brought some outsourced work back in-house in five years, and **68%** name control over service quality as a reason to insource.[^3]
> - Arbitrations at the International Chamber of Commerce that ended in a final award in 2025 took **27** months on average.[^4]
> - The median arbitration at the London Court of International Arbitration that reached a final award from 2017 to 12 May 2024 cost **USD 117,653**.[^5]

## Contracts Lose 8.6% of Their Value on Average

WorldCC's estimate draws on 1,236 organizations, through workshops, interviews, roundtables and online surveys between April 2021 and December 2022.[^1] The spread around it is wide: the best performers lose **a little over 3%** of contract value and the worst **more than 20%**.[^1]

The association's 2014 research, published under its old name IACCM, had put the average at **9.2%**.[^1] The 2023 study set out to see whether the investment since then, especially in technology, had driven significant progress, and found a marginal improvement.

By WorldCC's reading, most of the loss sits in the gap between what organizations say they will do and what happens,[^1] and part of the improvement it did find came from more attention to contracts after they are signed.[^1]

It adds that the more a contract needs specific monitoring, as performance-based and volume-based contracts do, the greater the potential for errors, omissions and disagreements.[^1]

A contact center contract that ties its fee to volume and its credits to performance is both, and both are worked out after signature, every month.

> An average of 8.6% reads like a figure for companies with legal departments. In an outsourcing business, part of it can sit in places that look small: a month's credit settled on the client's reading, an outage on the client's side nobody raised as an exclusion. Finding it takes the same arithmetic, done the same way for every client, before each review.
>
> Vlad Shvets, Partner @ Qvery

## Nearly Half of Companies Can't Say Who Owns Their Contracting

In WorldCC's 2025 benchmark, **48%** of respondents said there is no clarity over who is accountable for the quality and integrity of their contracting.[^2] The other **52%** said it was clear, and WorldCC, reading their answers, concluded that **70 to 80%** of organizations lack true accountability.[^2] WorldCC developed the benchmark with Sirion, which sells contract software.

Executives agree that it matters: **88%** in the same benchmark said contract management excellence does.[^2]

Deloitte measured where the time goes, with Docusign, which sells e-signature and agreement management software.[^6] It surveyed more than 1,000 business leaders in ten countries, all at companies with at least $25 million in annual revenue and 125 employees.[^7]

Companies with disconnected agreement management workflows spend an extra **18%** of their time on agreements, an average of **16 hours** more across an agreement's life.[^7]

Of the leaders surveyed, **62%** struggle to find contracts they already approved, **61%** have delays assigning an agreement's owner, and **45%** key data into contracts when it already sits in another system.[^7]

**62% Struggle to Find Contracts They Already Approved** (share of respondents)

62% of the business leaders surveyed struggle to locate contracts they already approved, 61% have delays assigning an agreement's owner, and 45% key in data that already sits in another system.

| Label | Value |
|---|---:|
| Struggle to locate and access previously approved contracts | 62% |
| Delays assigning ownership and support for an agreement | 61% |
| Lack tools to automate tracking and analytics | 54% |
| Gather contract data from several places before analyzing it | 50% |
| Key data into contracts that already exists in other systems | 45% |

Share of more than 1,000 business leaders in ten countries, all at companies with at least $25 million in annual revenue and 125 employees, naming each problem in how their company manages agreements; Deloitte's 2024 survey with Docusign, which sells e-signature and agreement management software. Source: Deloitte and Docusign: 2024 survey of agreement management (2024)

After signature the picture holds: **54%** lack tools to track and analyze their agreements automatically, and **50%** have to gather a contract's data from several places before they can analyze it.[^7]

Deloitte puts the cost of all this at **nearly $2 trillion** a year in lost productivity and revenue opportunities worldwide, $1.8 trillion in 2025 rising to $2.3 trillion by 2030.[^7]

It is a model built on a survey run with a company that sells agreement software, so read it as a direction, not a bill.

In an outsourcing firm, the reading of a credit clause can sit between the people who sold the contract, the people who run the program and the analyst who rebuilds the scorecard.

## Outsourcing Clients Struggle to Track What They Get

Deloitte's 2024 Global Outsourcing Survey asked more than 500 business and technology leaders, over 150 of them in the C-suite, about the services they buy.[^3] The challenge they named most often was a lack of tracking and reporting of the benefit, at **55%**.[^3]

**Tracking the Benefit Is the Challenge Outsourcing Clients Name Most** (share of respondents)

55% of outsourcing buyers name a lack of tracking and reporting of the benefit as a challenge, the most named, ahead of organizational change at 53%.

| Label | Value |
|---|---:|
| Tracking and reporting the benefit | 55% |
| Managing organizational change | 53% |
| Integrating vendor services with the operating model | 47% |
| Vendor performance during transitions | 46% |
| Financial management | 40% |
| Contract and contract change management | 38% |
| Managing vendor performance | 38% |
| Managing the vendor relationship | 36% |

Challenges organizations face in their outsourcing programs, as a share of the more than 500 business and technology leaders in Deloitte's 2024 Global Outsourcing Survey (the buyers of outsourcing). Respondents could name more than one; the eight most named are shown. Source: Deloitte: 2024 Global Outsourcing Survey (2024)

Poor vendor performance during transitions was named by **46%**, poor contract and contract change management by **38%**, and poor management of the vendor's performance also by **38%**.[^3]

For a provider, that makes the monthly service level report part of the answer: a report the client can check line by line gives it something to track.

Outcome-based models are spreading too. **67%** of the executives reported adopting managed or operate services, where the provider is paid for results rather than for staff, up from **45%** two years earlier, while **29%** still use staff augmentation.[^3]

Nearly **70%** say their vendor management office, the team that oversees suppliers, is not yet mature.[^3]

## Seven in Ten Clients Have Brought Some Work Back In-House

**70%** of the buyers in Deloitte's survey have brought part of their outsourced scope back in-house in the past five years, most of them very selectively.[^3] In the survey's table of reasons for insourcing, **68%** of respondents named better control over service quality and performance, the reason named most.[^3]

**Control Over Service Quality Is the Top Reason Clients Take Work Back** (share of respondents)

68% named better control over service quality and performance as a driver for insourcing, ahead of growing capabilities in-house at 64% and spend optimization at 56%.

| Label | Value |
|---|---:|
| Better control over service quality and performance | 68% |
| Grow strategic capabilities in-house | 64% |
| Spend optimization | 56% |
| Risk and security | 46% |
| Transparency in service operations | 39% |
| A more balanced sourcing mix | 39% |

Primary drivers for bringing outsourced scope or services back in-house, as a share of respondents to Deloitte's 2024 Global Outsourcing Survey; respondents could name more than one, and the six most named are shown. Source: Deloitte: 2024 Global Outsourcing Survey (2024)

Investment in outsourcing is still set to rise for **40%** of the buyers and fall for **20%**,[^3] while **54%** are exploring more insourcing and **39%** more outsourcing.[^3]

Cost has stopped being the main reason to outsource: **34%** named it in 2024, against **70%** four years earlier.[^3]

Deloitte also notes that even organizations reporting high satisfaction with their outsourcing are insourcing.[^3] Month-by-month proof of quality is a provider's evidence in that conversation, though it does not settle who keeps the scope.

> Before our agents read a month of data, each contract's service level schedule becomes plain rules: which calls count, the time windows, the clock pauses, the cap. Every rule quotes the clause it came from, and whoever owns the client confirms or corrects it. From then on every scorecard uses that version, so March and April are read the same way.
>
> Piotr Babel, Partner @ Qvery

## ICC Arbitrations Took 27 Months on Average to Reach a Final Award

In WorldCC's 2026 study of more than 350 organizations,[^8] dialogue comes before escalation and formal dispute processes are described as a last resort.[^8]

Suppliers told WorldCC they concede ground, even when they are not convinced by the customer's position, to protect the relationship.[^8] Consulting and technology firms showed a readiness to consider credits, renewals and governance resets.[^8]

The formal route is long at both institutions that publish these figures, the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) and the London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA), and the LCIA's median case cost six figures.

**How long a case took to reach a final award, and what it cost, by institution**

| Cases | Measure | Figure |
|---|---|---|
| ICC, final awards in 2025 | Average time | 27 months[^4] |
| ICC, final awards in 2025 | Median time | 23 months[^4] |
| LCIA, final awards from 1 January 2017 to 12 May 2024 | Median time, four months of it to write the award | 20 months[^5] |
| LCIA, same cases, claims under USD 1 million | Median time | 12 months[^5] |
| LCIA, same cases | Median cost, not adjusted for inflation (USD 97,000 in the previous analysis) | USD 117,653[^5] |
| ICC mediations, 2025 | Average and median cost, fees and expenses included | US$34,000 and US$25,900[^4] |

**881** cases were filed under the ICC Arbitration Rules in 2025,[^9] part of **894** new cases in all.[^4]

By sector, construction and engineering brought **28%** and energy **15%**, while business services brought **4.4%**.[^4] Counted by the type of contract instead, services contracts, a category in which the ICC counts consultancy, agency and loan contracts among others, made up **16.2%**.[^4]

**Services Contracts Were 16.2% of 2025 ICC Filings by Contract Type** (share of 2025 filings)

Services contracts, a category that in the ICC's count includes consultancy, agency and loan contracts, made up 16.2% of 2025 filings, behind construction and engineering at 21.5% and goods at 20.6%.

| Label | Value |
|---|---:|
| Construction and engineering | 21.5% |
| Goods (distribution, franchising, purchase and sale) | 20.6% |
| Services (consultancy, agency, loans and others) | 16.2% |
| Corporate (share transfer, partnership, joint venture) | 12.4% |

The most frequent types of contract in arbitrations filed with the ICC International Court of Arbitration in 2025, all sectors, as a share of filings; the ICC's own category names. Source: International Chamber of Commerce: ICC Dispute Resolution 2025 Statistics (2026)

The median new case was **US$5 million**,[^4] the average just over **US$50 million**, leaving out the 72 cases with no stated amount,[^4] and **41%** did not exceed US$4 million.[^9]

**346** cases were withdrawn before a final award in 2025, **53%** of those withdrawals before the tribunal was appointed;[^4] separately, **45** ended in an award by consent.[^4]

Set against 27 months and a median LCIA bill of USD 117,653, a disputed month of service credits is worth settling in the review, on numbers both sides can check.

## A Service Credit Is Arithmetic Both Sides Can Check

Each contract writes its own credits, and published terms show how one is built. For its compute service, Amazon Web Services commits to commercially reasonable efforts to keep each region at **99.99%** monthly uptime, for customers running across two or more of its availability zones in that region.[^10]

Below that, it credits **10%** of that month's compute bill in the region; below 99.0%, **30%**; below 95.0%, **100%**.[^10]

**Amazon Web Services' region-level compute credits, as published (last updated May 2022)**

| Monthly uptime in the region | Credit on that month's compute bill in the region |
|---|---|
| Below 99.99%, at least 99.0% | 10% |
| Below 99.0%, at least 95.0% | 30% |
| Below 95.0% | 100% |

To get the credit, the customer files a claim, which must arrive by the end of the second billing cycle after the incident.[^10]

The credit comes off future compute bills unless AWS chooses to put it on the card, it never entitles the customer to a refund, and unless the customer's agreement says otherwise it is the sole and exclusive remedy.[^10]

UK government guidance for public buyers sets limits from the buyer's side: service credits should be proportionate to the contract's value and risk, deductions should be capped at the contract's profit, not linked to revenue, and nothing should ratchet them up.[^11]

So a credit is worked out against the formula, and the cap where there is one, that both sides signed.

None of the sources on this page measures that arithmetic: how often a month's credit is worked out on the wrong reading, or how much of the 8.6% sits in it. It is the job these figures point to, and it is one we take on at Qvery.

> At Qvery, we help outsourcing companies stop paying credits their contracts don't call for, with custom AI agents that rebuild each client's scorecard and apply its credit formula.

Each month [the agents we build for this job](https://qvery.ai/sla-credit-calculation-agent/) read the service level schedule in every client contract: the measures, targets, weights, credit formula and cap. They rebuild answer times and abandons from the interval rows of your dialer export rather than the dashboard total, apply the formula and the cap, and show every step.

Where a definition reads two ways, such as whether a transferred call counts as answered, both results appear next to each other.

Your account manager gets the scorecard, and the days that pulled each target down, before the monthly review; the client sees it only when your team sends it. Your team picks the reading to stand behind and settles it with the client.

We ask only for the service level schedule, not the commercial pages, and sign a data processing agreement before the build.

You can see the scorecard on one client of your own: add a contract's service level schedule and a month's phone export, or use our sample contact center.

Free report: outsourcing/sla-credit-calculation

## The Monthly Review Is Where a Credit Gets Agreed

Read together, these figures point one way. The loss WorldCC measures runs at 8.6% of contract value on average, the challenge outsourcing clients name most is tracking the benefit, and an ICC arbitration that reached a final award in 2025 took 27 months on average.

Each client's scorecard, checked before the review, is where we start with an outsourcing company.

Qvery Works Out Your Service Credits Before Every Client Review: https://calendly.com/qvery-vlad/30min

For a provider of a few hundred people, the question these figures leave is who works out each client's month, and whether it is done the same way every time.

## Frequently asked questions



### What is a typical service credit in an outsourcing contract?

Each contract sets its own, and none of the sources on this page reports a typical figure for outsourcing providers. Published terms show how one is built: Amazon Web Services credits 10%, 30% or 100% of a month's compute bill in a region as its region-level uptime falls below 99.99%, 99.0% and 95.0%, on a claim.[^10] UK guidance tells public buyers to cap deductions at the contract's profit.[^11]

### Are service credits the only remedy for a missed service level?

They can be written that way. Amazon Web Services' agreement makes its credits the customer's sole and exclusive remedy for unavailability, unless the customer's agreement says otherwise,[^10] and UK guidance recommends that liquidated damages be the customer's sole and exclusive remedy for service failure.[^11] Whether that holds in your own contract depends on its wording and its exceptions, which is a question for your lawyer rather than for a scorecard.

### How long does a contract dispute take in arbitration, and what does it cost?

None of the sources on this page gives figures for outsourcing alone. Across all sectors, ICC arbitrations that ended in a final award in 2025 took 27 months on average and 23 at the median.[^4] At the LCIA, the median case that reached a final award between 1 January 2017 and 12 May 2024 took 20 months and cost USD 117,653, not adjusted for inflation.[^5]

### How many people in a company work on contracts?

More than most owners would guess. WorldCC's benchmarks suggest that on average 26% of an organization's workforce is involved in contracting in some way, and its research finds that some 90% of business people find contracts difficult or impossible to understand.[^1]

### Doesn't contract management software already fix this?

It helps, but the average barely moved. In WorldCC's research with Deloitte, 78% of organizations had invested in contract lifecycle management software in the past five years, most of them in the last year, and average value erosion still stood at 8.6%, against 9.2% in 2014.[^1]

### Where does the loss from poor agreement management fall?

Mostly in support functions. In Deloitte's model with Docusign, support functions such as procurement carry 60% of the value lost to poor agreement management, through wasted time and operating costs, and customer-facing functions such as sales and marketing carry 40%, through missed revenue opportunities such as deals that close late.[^7]

### How often do outsourcing disputes go to arbitration?

None of the sources on this page counts outsourcing disputes. At the ICC, 881 cases were filed under its Arbitration Rules in 2025 across all sectors;[^9] services contracts were 16.2% of filings by contract type,[^4] and business services 4.4% by sector.[^4] WorldCC's 2026 study found formal dispute processes described as a last resort, after dialogue and executive talks.[^8]

### How big are the disputes that reach arbitration?

Large next to a monthly credit. At the ICC in 2025, about half of the cases filed that year or still pending had between US$1 million and US$30 million in dispute,[^4] and 41% of new cases did not exceed US$4 million.[^9] These are figures for every sector, not for services alone.

### Who should own contract performance at an outsourcing firm?

Someone named, which many companies lack: 48% of respondents to WorldCC's 2025 benchmark said nobody clearly owns the quality of their contracting.[^2] At a provider, the person who takes the monthly review with a client is the natural owner of how that client's credit clause is read.

### Can an AI agent work out service credits from our dialer data?

Yes, once each contract's rules are fixed and confirmed by whoever owns the client. The agents we build read each contract's service level schedule, rebuild the month from your dialer's interval data, apply the formula and the cap, and show both results where a definition reads two ways. They never send anything to a client: your account manager sees the scorecard first, and your team picks the reading.

### What do the agents need from us, and what happens to client contracts?

The service level schedule of each contract, not its commercial pages, and the month's exports from your phone and ticket systems. Names, signatories and prices outside the credit formula can be removed first. Before the build we sign a data processing agreement that names where files are handled and who at Qvery can open them.

## Sources

[^1]: World Commerce & Contracting and Deloitte, "The ROI of Contracting Excellence" (2023), https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/us/Documents/Tax/us-tax-roi-of-contracting-excellence.pdf
[^2]: World Commerce & Contracting, "Benchmark Report 2025: The Race Is On, Navigating Uncertainty Through CCM Resilience" (2025), https://info.worldcc.com/benchmark-2025
[^3]: Deloitte, "2024 Global Outsourcing Survey" (2024), https://www.deloitte.com/content/dam/assets-shared/docs/services/consulting/2025/global-outsourcing-survey-2024.pdf
[^4]: International Chamber of Commerce, "ICC Dispute Resolution 2025 Statistics" (2026), https://iccwbo.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2026/08/ICC_2025_DRS_Statistics_Report_EN.pdf
[^5]: London Court of International Arbitration, "LCIA Releases Updated Costs and Duration Analysis 2024" (2024), https://www.lcia.org/News/lcia-releases-updated-costs-and-duration-analysis-2024.aspx
[^6]: Docusign, "About Docusign" (2026), https://www.docusign.com/company
[^7]: Deloitte and Docusign, "Unlocking the Value of Agreement Management" (2024), https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/us/Documents/Tax/us-tax-unlocking-the-value-of-agreement-management.pdf
[^8]: World Commerce & Contracting, "Beyond the Contract: A Global Study of How Disputes Arise, Escalate, and Get Resolved" (2026), https://info.worldcc.com/beyond-the-contract-2026
[^9]: International Chamber of Commerce, "ICC Dispute Resolution Statistics" (2026), https://iccwbo.org/dispute-resolution/resources/icc-dispute-resolution-statistics/
[^10]: Amazon Web Services, "Amazon Compute Service Level Agreement" (2022), https://aws.amazon.com/compute/sla/
[^11]: UK Government (Cabinet Office), "Risk Allocation and Pricing Approaches Guidance Note" (2026), https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-sourcing-and-consultancy-playbooks/risk-allocation-and-pricing-approaches-guidance-note-html
